About Tom Evslin

Video Profile of Tom Evslin

Follow Tom Evslin on Twitter


Add to Technorati Favorites!
Powered by TypePad
Member since 01/2005


« WHO Doesn’t Like the Gates Foundation | Main | Nerding Again: It's Hard »

Japan’s Internet Access Satellite Is a Mistake

CNN reports that “Japan launched a rocket Saturday carrying a satellite that will test new technology that promises to deliver "super high-speed Internet" service to homes and businesses around the world… If the technology proves successful, subscribers with small dishes will connect to the Internet at speeds many times faster than what is now available over residential cable or DSL services… the Associated Press said the satellite would offer speeds of up to 1.2 gigabytes per second [nb. with a seventeen foot dish].”

Sounds good but it isn’t.

What neither the Associated Press nor CNN picked up is the altitude at which the satellite is intended to orbit, probably because they don’t understand why that’s important. Slashdot was a little more discerning, however: they picked up that it is intended to be geostationary (always appearing in the same spot in the sky so that antennae can be pointed at it). Physics (and the release from the Japanese AerospaceExploration Agency) tell us that a geostationary satellite must be 22, 000 miles above the earth. Other laws of physics say that radio signals are going to take more than a tenth of a second to get there and the same time to get back; the universe apparently doesn’t allow faster speeds.

Not only does that mean that these satellites won’t be good for interactive gaming (as Slashdot points out) and that they’ll be terrible for VoIP; they also won’t work well for web browsing. That matters! A modern web page is built in many interactions between your computer and the host of the website (much more detail here); the minimum time for each of those interactions is half a second because the signal has to go up and down to get to the server and up and down to get back to you. Those half a seconds don’t sound like much but they add up (this delay is called “latency”). If you use satellite, you know how slow page builds are and how may pages just break during the delay. Unfortunately fast data rates don’t help when latency is the problem.

The satellite’ll be good for email; it’s a good backup to oceanic fiber that seems to be getting cut lately. It will NOT do what the Japanese Agency’s press release says: “…even in some areas where major ground infrastructure for the Internet is difficult to establish, people can enjoy the same level of Internet service as that in urban areas.” Cable, DSL, and even terrestrial wireless measure latency in milliseconds (thousandths of a second); latency is very often MORE important than bandwidth in determining the quality of Internet experience. Anyone who thinks geostationary satellites are an acceptable way to bring broadband to rural areas doesn’t understand how the modern web works.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Japan’s Internet Access Satellite Is a Mistake:


Satellite Internet Service

At the end of the day, return to relax in a deep bathtub.The lounge features satellite television, a selection of DVD movies, portable DVD player, speed internet access. http://www.broadband-high-speed-internet.com/1.html

Tracy Hall

Another point often missed with this (and with WiMax, for that matter) - footprint also matters - and not in a good way - all those subscribers in that footprint have to SHARE the connection. Even hundreds of gigabits may not seem much when shared by 10's to 100's of millions...

John Loerchner

Couldn't help but point out the irony.

"Nothing great has ever been accomplished without irrational exuberance"

Seems like the japanese might have a case of irrational exuberance...that might not end up in a great accomplishment.

Don Price

Everyone that I meet which is using geostationary satellite services today (unfortunately there are many in Vermont in this predicament) can say many things negative about the service and only one thing positive: it is better than dial up. Not much of a recommendation in my book. The practical experience is satellite services are in fact only good for one way communications.

It fails me to understand why with all the many different terrestrial or near terrestrial means to create a network a space based platform is deemed so attractive. Take case in point www.angelhalo.com as just one example of the interesting ideas, not all the high tech, to bring broadband access to the market.

Barry Kelly

The way I see it, huge bandwidth isn't terribly useful for web browsing. As you say, it's low latency that really makes the difference, once the bandwidth is anyway decent at all.

However, there are other uses that aren't so latency-sensitive. I'm thinking of video streaming in particular. Maybe not what the Japanese are promoting, but I sense that maybe somebody pushed a different agenda (maybe for government funding) while actually trying to corner the future of TV.

Just a wild guess, when faced with an odd set of facts...


The other problem with satcom is uplink. The English version says it is going to be a respectable 6 Mbps. But in a Japanese version it looks like it can be as low as 1.5 Mbps (take a look at the last paragraph at http://www.jaxa.jp/pr/brochure/pdf/04/sat07.pdf). Of course all these are moot if the focus of the demonstration is only for disaster recovery applications.


Shinakansen Internet



Shinakansen Internet


Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In.

Now on Kindle!

hackoff.com: An historic murder mystery set in the Internet bubble and rubble

CEO Tom Evslin's insider account of the Internet bubble and its aftermath. "This novel is a surveillance video of the seeds of the current economic collapse."

The Interpreter's Tale

Hacker Dom Montain is in Barcelona in Evslin's Kindle-edition long short story. Why? and why are the pickpockets stealing mobile phones?

Need A Kindle?

Kindle: Amazon's Wireless Reading Device

Not quite as good as a real book IMHO but a lot lighter than a trip worth of books. Also better than a cell phone for mobile web access - and that's free!

Recent Reads - Click title to order from Amazon


  • adlinks
  • adsense